Named.

“Who is the best personal injury lawyer in Livingston, Montana?”

Asked October 15, 2026 with Claude and live web search, the way a customer asks. It read 9 pages and named 5 businesses.

Named, in order

  1. 1Walter H. "Lefty" Madden
  2. 2Law Office of Karl Knuchel, PC
  3. 3Kevin S. Brown
  4. 4Scott Stinson
  5. 5Towe & Fitzpatrick, PLLC

Run a personal injury lawyer in Livingston?

Check where you land, or see exactly why these names come up first.

What it read

  • lawyers.findlaw.comFind Livingston, Montana Personal Injury Lawyers
  • justia.comBest Personal Injury Lawyers in Livingston, MT
  • justia.comBest Lawyers in Livingston, MT
  • profiles.superlawyers.comTop Rated Livingston, MT Personal Injury Attorney
  • lawyers.comKevin S. Brown - Livingston, MT Attorney
  • findapersonalinjuryattorney.comLivingston Personal Injury Lawyer
  • lawmontana.comLivingston Personal Injury Attorney
  • lawyers.lawyerlegion.comLivingston, Montana Personal Injury Lawyers on Lawyer Legion
  • injuryattorney.reviewsBest Injury Attorneys in Livingston, Montana

The full answer

No one lawyer is objectively the "best." The right choice depends on your type of case, such as a car crash, medical malpractice, or a workplace injury. Here are some well-regarded options I found, with Livingston-based lawyers listed first:

Based in Livingston

  • Walter H. "Lefty" Madden (Law Office of Karl Knuchel, PC): Super Lawyers lists him as a top-rated personal injury attorney in Livingston. Getting on that list requires passing their selection process.
  • Kevin S. Brown: He handles personal injury, medical malpractice and criminal cases, and has been licensed for about 30 years.
  • Scott Stinson: Justia lists his practice areas as personal injury, business and criminal law. He's a former public defender who has taken over 100 cases to verdict.

Serves Livingston from elsewhere

  • Towe & Fitzpatrick, PLLC (based in Missoula): FindLaw says they offer free consultations and have 31 years of experience.

How to choose

  1. Look for the right experience. Ask how many cases like yours they've handled and how those cases turned out.
  2. Talk to two or three lawyers. Most personal injury lawyers offer a free first meeting.
  3. Ask about fees. Most work on contingency, meaning they take a share of what you win, often 33–40%. Ask how case costs are handled.
  4. Check their record. The State Bar of Montana will show whether a lawyer is in good standing or has been disciplined.
  5. Find out who will do the work. Ask whether the lawyer you meet will handle your case personally.
  6. Consider bigger firms for serious cases. For a major trucking accident or wrongful death case, it may be worth asking Bozeman or Billings firms with more resources. Many of them take cases from Park County.

You can compare more lawyers and read reviews on FindLaw, Justia, Super Lawyers and Avvo.

Act soon. In Montana you generally have three years from the date of an injury to file a lawsuit, and some claims have shorter deadlines.

Earlier answers

  • October 15, 2026: Luebeck, Hammar, McCarty & Goldwarg, Morgan & Morgan, Gravis Law PLLC, Towe & Fitzpatrick, PLLC, Morrison Sherwood Wilson Deola PLLP

This page reports what Claude said. It is not our ranking or an endorsement. Nobody paid to be named, and nobody can.